These Caramilk cheesecake cups are individual serves of Caramilk cheesecake served in elegant glasses, the perfect make ahead dessert for your next dinner party! (or just a Tuesday night - no judgement)
Hands up all my Caramilk lovers out there...I see you! This is a recipe that will be right up your Caramilk alley, my Caramilk cheesecake cups. Gorgeous individual serves of creamy Caramilk cheesecake in a glass - looks super fancy but is really super easy and a no bake, make ahead dessert dream!
Table of Contents
Ingredients you will need for this recipe
- Caramilk chocolate
- cream cheese
- cream
- vanilla
- biscuits/cookies - I used Butternut Snap Cookies
- salted butter
- light brown sugar
- icing/confectioners sugar - optional
- Caramilk Twirl bar - to decorate
*Please see the recipe card below for exact quantities and detailed instructions
How to make Caramilk cheesecake cups
- Place biscuits into a food processer and process into fine crumbs, reserving some crumbs for decoration. Then add combined melted butter and light brown sugar and process until mixed, then set aside.
- Melt Caramilk chocolate in the microwave and set aside.
- Mix cream cheese until smooth, then add vanilla and melted Caramilk and mix to combine.
- In a separate bowl, whip the cream.
- Then add whipped cream to Caramilk cream cheese mixture and mix until combined.
- Taste test for sweetness, adding confectioners sugar if required.
- Divide biscuit mixture evenly between four glasses.
- Spoon or pipe Caramilk cheesecake mixture over the biscuit base then decorate with reserved biscuit crumbs and pieces of Caramilk Twirl.
My top tips for making this recipe
- The glasses I have used in the photos are 400ml (approx 1 ⅔ cup) capacity.
- I have used pure cream (35% milk fat with no thickeners added), but any kind of cream will be fine as long as it can be whipped (you may need to check the package).
- I have included icing/confectioners sugar as an optional ingredient because I find the Caramilk cheesecake mixture sweet enough without it. But, having said that sugar can be a bit like salt in a recipe like this in that people's preferences can vary a lot. This is why I suggest that you put it in last, so you can have a taste test first.
Other recipes you may enjoy
Banoffee Cups with a Surprise Twist - cream, banana, caramel and...peanut butter!!!! Take your banoffee pie experience to the next level...I promise you won't be sorry!
Caramilk White Christmas Slice - this Christmas classic is packed with fruit, nuts, coconut & puffed rice but using Caramilk chocolate in place of the usual white chocolate.
Want to save this recipe?
📖 Recipe

Caramilk Cheesecake Cups
Ingredients
- 140 g biscuits/cookies I used Butternut Snap Cookies
- 40 g salted butter melted
- 1 teaspoon light brown sugar
- 180 g block of Caramilk chocolate broken into squares
- 225 g cream cheese softened
- 250 ml pure cream 35% milk fat with no thickeners added
- ½ teaspoon vanilla
- icing/confectioners sugar to taste optional
- 35 g Caramilk Twirl bar broken into pieces to decorate
Instructions
- Place biscuits into a food processor and process into fine crumbs, then remove 1 tablespoon of crumbs to reserve for decoration.140 g biscuits/cookies
- Combine melted butter and light brown sugar then add to the biscuit crumbs in the processor and process until mixed, then set aside.40 g salted butter1 teaspoon light brown sugar
- Melt Caramilk chocolate in the microwave in 30 second bursts (mixing with a metal spoon between bursts) and set aside to cool slightly.180 g block of Caramilk chocolate
- In a large bowl, mix cream cheese until smooth, then add vanilla and melted Caramilk and mix to combine.225 g cream cheese½ teaspoon vanilla
- In a separate bowl, whip the cream then add whipped cream to Caramilk cream cheese mixture and mix until combined. Taste test for sweetness, adding confectioners sugar (a small amount at a time) if required.250 ml pure creamicing/confectioners sugar to taste
- Divide biscuit mixture evenly between four glasses, then spoon or pipe Caramilk cheesecake mixture on top of the biscuit base. Decorate with reserved biscuit crumbs and pieces of Caramilk Twirl.35 g Caramilk Twirl bar
Notes
- The glasses I have used in the photos are 400ml (approx 1 ⅔ cup) capacity.
- I have used pure cream (35% milk fat with no thickeners added), but any kind of cream will be fine as long as it can be whipped (you may need to check the package).
- I have included icing/confectioners sugar as an optional ingredient because I find the Caramilk cheesecake mixture sweet enough without it. But, having said that sugar can be a bit like salt in a recipe like this in that people's preferences can vary a lot. This is why I suggest that you put it in last, so you can have a taste test first.
Want to save this recipe?







I was really glad when caramilk came back. This was easy to make for a dinner party at home. All loved it!
Glad they were a hit Kath!
Could these be made the night before? 😊 I plan to make these this weekend and super excited! But will try in a trifle bowl instead of mini cups
Sure Bridget! Just keep it well covered in the fridge. The trifle bowl sounds like a great idea too!
Thank you!
Made mini ones and a big one and delicious!!!!!!! Definitely adding them to my list of favorites:D
Woo hooooo! Thanks for letting me know Bridget!
Wow. These caramilk cheesecake cups look so delicious!! What a decadent dessert perfect for having company over.
Amazing!!!!!